Super Permalinks

Fri, 18 May 2007

Someone asked me if my site will have permalinks (yes - I'm not changing any links) and it reminded me of a technique which I read about quite some time ago by Thomas Phelps and Robert Wilensky:

Traditional hyperlinks are very brittle, in that they are useless if the page later moves to a different URL. This project improves upon traditional hyperlinks by creating a signature of the target page, selecting a set of very rare words that uniquely identify the page, and relying on a search engine query for those rare words to find the page in the future. For example, the Google programming contest can be found using this link. (source)

The idea is that instead of remembering the location of something, you remember a little bit of the content there, since that is what you acually care about. Then when the location changes, the content stays the same, so you can still find it. I thought it was a cool idea at the time, so whenever I was at a website, I would try to remember a few unusual words that it contained so if I ever wanted to get back there, I could just google for those words. It worked, but I've stopped doing it for no real reason.

a nocturnal, melodic, bag of phonetic sugar in a cliffhanger situation that is indistinguishable from its buddy, and has been shortchanged by the beverage machine. Take my word on it that it is metaphysical, and that it is somehow subcontracting.

So, if you want to try it. Then just remember a few of the following words: indistinguishable, subcontracting, metaphysical, cliffhanger, melodic, phonetic, shortchanged, nocturnal, sugar. At the moment a search for all of these words comes up with 48 hits but hopefully that will change in the future. At the moment google doesn't even know this page exists, so it will be a while before this is useful. I've produced a visual aid for you to remember them by - simple (though I couldn't work out how to make the sugar metaphysical, and drawing a contract above a bag of sugar is supposed to suggest "sub" contracting which is a bit loose).

As a closing note, I tried to look at the actual paper, and I got a server error. I don't think that is irony, since the link to it was just a normal link. But I still found it amusing.

One other amusing thing is that the example link in that quote (this link) has its first hit as a page about the technique, rather than the Google programming contest page.
Andy
1 hour after story
that is more like a memory un-aid haha. I'm sure I will have some strange dreams about it though :P

looking forward to some enlightenment!
IGTHORN
2 days after story
you got your permalink apparently
100 days after story
Interesting approach, but isn't it subject to google bombing? A few people could copy your words into their blogs and the permalink would suddenly become a whole lot noisier.
rich
105 days after story
I don't think anyone will claim it is perfect - but for what it is trying to protect against, it is quite robust I would think.
Andy
108 days after story
Name & email are optional. Email will not be obfuscated.
HTML tags will be removed except hyperlinks.
 

About

I'm a nerd living in Sydney. This is a place where I can write stuff about my interests and not care that no one else is reading.

I like music, maths, programming, pretty pictures, filters and other good things.

(more info)

It should be fairly obvious that this isn't connected to my employer at all.

Email me (not a catchpa)

Email policy

Subscribe

RSS Feed RSS

Get an aggregator

Liferea (Linux)

Vienna (OSX)

Feedreader (Windows)

Google Reader (Web based)

I've only used Liferea, so I can't vouch for the other ones.

About this site

This site runs a (modified) version of blosxom.

The host is GeekISP, and they seem to do an excellent job.